Multnomah, Washington county sheriffs give their take on guns - KPTV - FOX 12

Multnomah, Washington county sheriffs give their take on gun control laws

Posted: Updated:

Sheriffs from two of Oregon's largest counties are now sounding off on gun control proposals in the wake of Linn County Sheriff Tim Mueller telling Vice President Joe Biden he will not enforce new gun control laws that he feels are unconstitutional.

Sheriff Pat Garrett, from Washington County, said he will not enforce federal law that will infringe upon Second Amendment rights.

He issued the following letter:

Washington County Citizens,

I will protect your Second Amendment rights under the United States Constitution -I will
not enforce federal law that will infringe upon those rights.

Saying that, I think it also helpful to take a breath and rationally consider what is likely and unlikely to happen with respect to the Second Amendment. First, I do not believe any branch of the federal government will unilaterally be successful in passing law that restricts your Second Amendment rights.

Our system of government ensures that any new law passed by Congress must be signed by the President, and is subject to being struck down by the courts if found to violate our Constitution. Second, in light of the Supreme Court's last two decisions on gun rights, I cannot conceive that the Court will find any significant additional regulation of firearms constitutional. Finally, I think it highly likely that if any new gun control law appears, it will be quickly challenged and rendered unenforceable pending the final outcome of judicial review.

Our Constitution, as you know, created three branches of government. Each has separate roles. The Executive Branch carries out current law and recommends new laws; the Legislative Branch creates law; and the Judicial Branch (Supreme Court) interprets laws, the Constitution, and decides cases involving states' rights. The separation of powers among the branches guarantees checks and balances, especially in times where one branch might be motivated to take unilateral action.

A good example of our system at work is the Supreme Court decision in Prinz v. United States. That case tested a federal statute that required local officials to carry out portions of federal law under the Brady Bill. In this case the Court found that the federal government may not constitutionally require local officials to enforce federal law and the court held that the statute was unconstitutional.

As a sheriff (executive branch) there is no question that I am bound to uphold the law. In addition, the writers of our Constitution made it very clear that interpreting the law is not my role. The federal Congress has enacted statutes that clearly establish federal law enforcement authority. Those statutes have been challenged, and the Supreme Court has held that the statutes are valid and constitutional. I do not get to substitute my own judgment about what the law is or should be - to do so would violate the basic principle of separation of power established by our Constitution.

Yesterday the President announced 23 executive actions. I support recommendations around
background checks, safe schools, and adding capacity to mental health services. I do not support action that would prevent law abiding Washington County citizens from possessing certain firearms or ammunition magazines. I will clearly communicate my position to our congressional delegation.


Sheriff Pat Garrett

Meanwhile, Multnomah County Sheriff Dan Staton issued his own statement, saying he has no plans to "make any immediate change of policy or practice" in regards to gun control measures proposed by elected officials locally or nationally.

To the Citizens of Multnomah County:

Recent media events have triggered an energized and sometimes reactive dialogue regarding gun control in our country. As a result, our Office has received multiple inquiries as to our position on gun control and the Second Amendment generally. In response, I would like to issue the following statement:

The first line of my Oath of Office is that I will support the Constitution of the United States, and I have and intend to continue to do that very thing. I support the rights of citizens granted by the Constitution, and have worked hard to ensure those rights are protected. This work has been both locally and through work with other Sheriff's at the state legislature, where I have supported rights to privacy for concealed handgun holders in my county, and tougher screening of concealed handgun applicants overall.

I do not, however, plan to make any immediate change of policy or practice with regard to recent reports I have heard of gun control measures proposed by elected officials locally or nationally. No change in the practices of this Office will come without both a clear understanding of the measures proposed or enacted into law, or a chance to hear back from the citizens of Multnomah County regarding these proposals. Nor do I believe that a fast-tracked approach will be effective in improving what is a very complex issue in our country.

I am personally shocked and saddened by the recent events that have brought these issues front and center, and I will be engaged with my fellow elected officials, public safety partners and the citizens of this county as we thoughtfully consider what measures might be taken to curb the violence seen in these recent events.

Thank you,
Sheriff Dan Staton

Already, sheriffs from a half-dozen other Oregon counties have issued statements on the gun control proposals.

Copyright 2013 KPTV-KPDX Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved.

Powered by WorldNow
FOX 12
Powered by WorldNow CNN
All content © 2014, KPTV-KPDX Broadcasting Corporation, Portland, OR and WorldNow. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.